Overview: W 42nd St, New York City
W 42nd St is a student housing property located in Midtown Manhattan (New York, NY, USA). It offers units described as three‑bedroom (3b) and apartment‑style. Monthly prices range from USD 1,800 to USD 2,450 (indicative — confirm with the operator). The minimum lease term is six months. Amenities include a Smart TV, kitchenware, and high‑speed Wi‑Fi.
The property has a Google rating of 4.8 based on 61 reviews. Internal satisfaction scores (out of 5) from the operator are: staff 5, social 5, cleaning 5, internet 5, location 5, amenities 3.5, value for money 5.
New York City’s overall “from‑price” (lowest listing on the platform) is USD 850 per month, meaning W 42nd St sits at a higher price point than the cheapest shared rooms in the city.
Who This Residence Suits
W 42nd St works well for students who:
- Value community and social life. Multiple reviews highlight the community atmosphere. Resident Kevin Martin wrote: “It has a great community and a lot to offer.” If you enjoy meeting people in shared spaces, this may be a good fit.
- Want well‑maintained shared facilities. Kevin Martin also noted: “The kitchen, showers, and bathrooms have been well maintained.” The internal score for cleaning is 5 out of 5, indicating consistent upkeep.
- Prefer a robust support staff. The internal staff rating is 5 out of 5, and Liv Harriger mentioned that moving staff were “so so helpful” when she arrived exhausted from a flight. This suggests a responsive team for check‑in and logistical issues.
- Are comfortable with a small private room in exchange for generous communal areas. Kevin Martin described: “The room is small but you make it work. Plus there’s a lot of communal space to hang out/work in so you’…” – the rest of the sentence is cut off, but it implies the communal spaces compensate.
- Need high‑speed internet and modern appliances. The property listing explicitly includes “High Speed Wifi” and “Smart TV,” plus kitchenware for daily cooking.
- Require a six‑month minimum lease. Many student leases run semester‑long, and six months fits a typical academic term.
Who This Residence Does Not Suit
Consider other options if you:
- Have strict expectations for overnight visitors. A 1‑star review by Aura Wang states: “I paid $6000 to stay here, and was blindsided by an overnight visitor policy that requires me to pay for an individual to stay over and I am allowed 7 days per calendar month of overnight visits. … They claim ‘visitors are a privilege, not a right’ like it’s a jail.” If you frequently host guests or expect a flexible visitor policy, W 42nd St may not meet your needs.
- Prioritise a large private bedroom. The same reviewer also describes the room as small. While communal spaces exist, those who want ample personal space should expect a compact sleeping area.
- Are on a tight budget. The minimum monthly price of USD 1,800 is more than double the city’s from‑price of USD 850. Even if split across three roommates (for the 3b unit), per‑person costs likely start around USD 600–800 before utilities – still above the cheapest shared rooms in the outer boroughs. Confirm exact per‑person pricing with the operator.
- Dislike restrictive policies. The visitor policy described (“7 days per calendar month” and a fee) is a potential friction point if you value autonomy.
What Residents Actually Say
Resident reviews are mixed but predominantly positive, with one strong negative perspective. Below are the verbatim quotes from the platform data (with ellipses indicating truncation in the original source).
Kevin Martin (5 stars) – “I’ve been staying at EHS Hudson Yards for a little over 2 months and it has been a great experience so far! It has a great community and a lot to offer. The kitchen, showers, and bathrooms have been well maintained. The room is small but you make it work. Plus there’s a lot of communal space to hang out/work in so you’”
Liv Harriger (5 stars) – “The EHS moving team was so so helpful! I had literally just gotten off my flight from TEXAS and ubered here with 5 bags and a cat that I was carrying by myself and they were so incredibly nice and took everything to my room while I checked in. I was so exhausted from traveling with my cat and they made the process so e”
Aura Wang (1 star) – “I paid $6000 to stay here, and was blindsided by an overnight visitor policy that requires me to pay for an individual to stay over and I am allowed 7 days per calendar month of overnight visits. Insane. Like I am not a grown adult. They claim ‘visitors are a privilege, not a right’ like it’s a jail. For what I am payi”
(Note: The review texts were cut off in the source. The excerpts above are exactly as provided.)
The overall Google rating of 4.8 from 61 reviews suggests that most residents have had positive experiences. However, the single negative review highlights a specific policy that is important to verify before booking.
Price Positioning vs. City From‑Price
New York City’s lowest listing on the platform is USD 850 per month. W 42nd St’s range (USD 1,800 – USD 2,450 monthly) is significantly above that entry‑level price. This positioning reflects:
- Location: Midtown Manhattan (42nd Street) is a high‑demand area with premium rental costs.
- Facilities: Smart TV, kitchenware, high‑speed Wi‑Fi, and communal spaces.
- Service: Staff scores are perfect (5/5), and the on‑site team appears responsive.
For comparison, the city’s 212 total properties include many budget options in outer boroughs or shared rooms. W 42nd St is a mid‑to‑upper range offering. If you are comfortable paying a premium for location and service, the value‑for‑money score is 5/5, indicating that most residents feel the cost is justified.
All prices are indicative — confirm exact rates and any additional fees (utilities, deposits, visitor charges) with the operator.
Room‑Type Guidance
The property lists two unit types:
- 3b (three‑bedroom): Likely a shared apartment with private bedrooms and common areas. Suitable for groups of three who want to split costs. Ensure you confirm the layout and whether the kitchen/living room is shared.
- Apartment: Could be a studio or one‑bedroom unit. Given the price range, a one‑bedroom may be at the upper end (USD 2,450). Verify the exact configuration with the operator.
Recommendation: If you are looking for a private studio in Midtown, the “apartment” option may work, but the price is high for a single person. A three‑bedroom could bring your share to roughly USD 600–800 per month (if split equally), making it more affordable. However, the negative review mentions paying USD 6,000 (likely for a longer stay or a larger unit) – clarify total costs upfront.
Booking Timing
- Availability: The platform data shows “available_from: null” (no specific date). This means availability changes frequently. For a semester starting in Fall 2026 or Spring 2027, contact the operator as early as possible – at least 3–6 months in advance.
- Minimum stay: 6 months, which aligns with typical academic terms. If you need a shorter lease (e.g., summer), this property may not suit.
- High demand: With a 4.8 rating and prime location, units likely fill quickly. Monitor the listing on the platform and reach out directly for current availability.
Frequently Asked Questions
H3: What is the overnight visitor policy?
Based on a resident’s 1‑star review, overnight visitors are limited to 7 days per calendar month and may incur an additional fee. The policy was described as restrictive. Always confirm the exact terms with the operator before signing the lease.
H3: Are utilities included in the monthly rent?
The provided data does not specify whether electricity, water, gas, or internet are included. High‑speed Wi‑Fi is listed as an amenity, but other utility costs may be separate. Ask the operator for a full breakdown of what the monthly price covers.
H3: Can I book a room for a shorter period than six months?
The minimum lease term is 6 months. No shorter stays are listed. If you need a 4‑ or 5‑month term, consider other properties or negotiate with the operator.
Sources & Data Date
This review is based on listing data provided by the platform (amberstudent.com) for the property “W 42nd St” (ID: amber‑267016) and publicly available reviews from Google. All prices are indicative. Data accuracy as of July 2026.
For live availability and current pricing, use the on‑site assistant to check directly with the operator.
See also: listing details · browse more