Rooming Houses, 23 Mountfield Avenue, Malvern East: A Factual Resident Review
This accommodation at 23 Mountfield Avenue in Malvern East, Melbourne, operates as a rooming house managed by a company referred to in resident reviews as “RoomingKos.” It offers ensuite rooms and apartments on a weekly rental basis. The following analysis draws on verified data, quoted resident feedback, and market context to help you decide whether this property meets your needs.
Who This Residence Suits (and Who Should Look Elsewhere)
This property is best suited for students or young professionals who prioritise a private ensuite and a central location in Malvern East, an established residential suburb about 12 km from Melbourne’s CBD. The presence of communal kitchens, laundry facilities, and WiFi (as listed under tags) suggests a shared-living model that works for those comfortable with common areas. The property’s Google rating of 4.8 from 261 reviews indicates high overall satisfaction among a large sample, which is unusual for a rooming house and points to a generally positive experience for most residents.
However, the same reviews reveal that the experience is highly variable. Two one-star reviews (out of the three provided) describe serious problems: incorrect password on arrival, delayed response, and what one reviewer calls “deeply disappointing and misleading experience” with advertising. This means the property may not suit anyone with a low tolerance for administrative hiccups, or those expecting a seamless move-in process. If you are arriving from overseas and cannot afford any delays or miscommunication, you may want to weigh these negative accounts carefully.
The minimum lease term is 29 weeks, which aligns with a typical academic semester. This favours students who need a fixed-term commitment rather than short-stay or month-by-month flexibility. The property is available from 8 July 2026, so early-to-mid-year arrivals should plan accordingly. Those seeking a non-communal, fully independent apartment with a private kitchen should note that the unit types are “ensuite” and “apartment” – the former likely means a bedroom with private bathroom but shared kitchen, while the latter may include a small kitchenette. Confirm with the operator before booking.
What Residents Actually Say
The three available Google reviews present a stark contrast. The positive review (Tri Kurnia Revul Andina, 5 stars) highlights value and comfort: “I have great experiences living here (Roomingkos Dudley Street). Firstly, the renting price is reasonable, considering the location is very strategic and the room is ensuite! With AC and heater. Secondly, the kitchen is communal but it is always clean, the stoves are many, and everyone gets fridges.”
The negative reviews (Yanyu Lau, 1 star; Jake Berrns, 1 star) describe failures in customer service and misrepresentation. Yanyu Lau writes: “Overall I have had a very terrible experience with this company I would list down everything I have experienced and I just want other people to know what it is actually like renting from rooming Kos First day, the password they gave was incorrect, they picked up my car after three or four hours, and asked me if it was …” (the review cuts off). Jake Berrns goes further: “Deeply Disappointing and Misleading Experience … First and foremost, the advertising is incredibly …” Also cut off.
While we cannot see the full text, the fragments clearly indicate unmet expectations around the initial move-in process and the accuracy of advertising. The positive review mentions “Roomingkos Dudley Street” – note that the property in question is on Mountfield Avenue, not Dudley Street. It is possible the reviewer lived at a different property under the same management. This ambiguity means you should treat the positive review as general feedback about the operator rather than this specific address.
The overall Google rating of 4.8 suggests that the negative experiences are outliers. Yet the fact that two of the three featured reviews are one-star – and from different authors – means the management may have consistency issues. When reading reviews on the source platform, look for patterns regarding move-in procedures, room condition, and responsiveness.
Price Positioning and Room Options
The weekly price range is AUD 280 to AUD 420 (indicative – confirm with the operator). This places the property above Melbourne’s city-wide from-price of AUD 219 per week, which typically reflects the cheapest available room in a shared apartment or student accommodation. The premium likely reflects the ensuite format and the Malvern East location, which is a mature suburban area with good transport links and proximity to Caulfield campus and other educational precincts (though we do not name specific institutions here).
For comparison, at the lower end of AUD 280, you are paying about 28% more than the city baseline. At AUD 420, you are paying nearly double the baseline – so it is essential to confirm what you get for the higher price. The unit types listed are “ensuite” and “apartment.” An ensuite typically provides a private bathroom attached to the bedroom but uses a shared or communal kitchen. An apartment may offer a self-contained kitchen and living area. Check with the operator whether the “apartment” option includes a private kitchen, as this can significantly affect your living experience and expenses.
Given the mixed reviews about advertising accuracy, it is wise to request a floor plan and a live video tour or virtual visit before committing to a higher-priced unit. Also confirm whether utilities (electricity, water, gas, internet) are included in the weekly rent. The tags indicate “wifi” is available, but the cost structure should be verified.
Booking Timing and What to Expect
The property becomes available on 8 July 2026, with a minimum lease of 29 weeks. This aligns with the second semester start for many Australian universities (late July). If you need accommodation for the first semester (February 2026), this property will not be ready – look for others that open earlier.
Because negative reviews mention failures on the first day (incorrect password, delayed handover), it is prudent to book well in advance and insist on written confirmation of arrival procedures. Allow a buffer of at least one week between your arrival in Melbourne and your intended move-in date, so that any issues can be resolved without leaving you homeless. The operator’s responsiveness before booking can serve as a signal for what to expect after.
There is no deposit amount listed in the data, but rooming houses in Victoria typically require a bond equivalent to four weeks’ rent, lodged with the Residential Tenancies Bond Authority (RTBA). Ensure you receive a receipt and a bond lodgement number. Avoid paying any amount via direct bank transfer to a personal account – use a legitimate payment portal.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is the property close to public transport and shops?
Malvern East has train stations (Malvern, Caulfield) and tram routes along Dandenong and Wattletree roads. The address is 23 Mountfield Avenue, which is a quiet residential street. You can expect a 10–15 minute walk or a short bus ride to major transport hubs. Confirm exact distances with the operator.
What if I need to stay longer than 29 weeks?
The minimum lease is 29 weeks. You may be able to extend on a week-by-week basis after the initial term, but this is not guaranteed. Ask the operator before signing whether rollover is possible and if rent will change. Some rooming houses require you to vacate at the end of the fixed term.
How reliable is the 4.8 Google rating given the negative reviews?
A 4.8 rating from 261 reviews suggests that the vast majority of residents have had a positive experience. The negative reviews we quoted may reflect isolated incidents or earlier management practices. However, the consistency of complaints about advertising and first-day processes means you should not ignore them. Cross-check recent reviews (from 2025–2026) on the Google My Business page and look for management responses that indicate how issues were resolved.
Sources & data date: 2026-07. Data retrieved from property listing on 2026-07-08. Prices and availability are indicative – confirm with the operator before booking.
For live availability at this property and others in Melbourne, use the on-site assistant to check current room options and move-in dates.
See also: listing details · browse more